Why Wind Will Not Work

Everyone is talking about global warming andwind farm is less predictable, makingthe balance
climate change, butfew people seem to realisemore difficult. If wind accounts for 3% or 4%
that Britain faces an energy crisisin just a fewofcapacity as at present, fluctuations can be
years. Why? First, we have changedabsorbed by usingother generators. Much more
fromself-sufficiency in energy to a net energythan 10% and the whole grid will behopelessly
importer in ageneration. We import 60% of ourunstable.
coal, 10% of our gas and afteryears of plenty weAll this assumes the project will be built, but there
are starting to import oil again. We use moregasis muchlocal opposition. They object to the 234
than anything else - for generating electricity, forturbines, 140m highwith rotors describing a 100m
cookingand heating our homes, for poweringdiameter. They object to the 35mile run of 141
industry - and by 2010 80%of gas will come frompylons, each of which will be 27m high.
abroad.Theyobject to the 104 miles of new road, the
In October 2006 a new pipeline from Norwaynine substations andthe control building. Once the
was commissioned; bigenough to supply 20% ofpower is brought ashore, thereare objections to
the UK's requirements. Other importscome fromthe 50-mile pylon route through the Highlands.
Algeria in tankers, or by pipeline from theIf the objections are overcome it will probably be
Netherlands, Germany or Russia. Russia has theten yearsbefore we can reasonably expect the
biggest reservesof gas in Europe, and by 2020 itelectricity to flow from the
will be the principal supplierto the UK and other EULewis Wind Farm. Supply shortages are predicted
countries. In January 2006 Russia was indisputeas little as 3years from now.
with Ukraine and cut off its gas. In fact, theA windmill on your roof
pipelinesto Hungary and the Czech Republic goWhy not put a windmill on your roof at home?
through Ukraine, so Ukrainesolved the problem byYou can generateyour own electricity and if you
cutting off those countries and keepingtheir gashave a surplus you can sell itback to the grid. You
for itself. Britain is at the far end of theeven get a grant from the government.
pipeline,and any problems in between us andUnfortunately there are problems and a domestic
Russia could cut off our gas.turbine is veryunlikely to save you money or
Britain's power stations are aging and nearly all willproduce a worthwhile amount ofelectricity.
need tobe replaced by 2020. At the moment theThere are several domestic turbines available
generators seem to bedragging their feet untilfrom £1500installed and rated to save you
they see a clear government policy onenergyabout 30% of your electricitybill. For a typical
pricing, carbon taxes and carbon trading. In thehome that is £300 per year, so the unit
meantime they work on extending the life ofpaysfor itself in 5 years and after that it's all
existing plant and hopethat it does not get lessprofit. In fact,most turbines produce their rated
reliable as it gets older.output at wind speeds ofaround 12 metres per
What's the alternative? What about wind?second, but if you go to the DTI's windspeed
There is a plan to build the biggest wind-farm indatabase, which is searchable by postcode, you
Europe on theisland of Lewis in the Outerwill findthat the average speed for most of the
Hebrides. Lewis Wind Power hasapplied to installBritish Isles is littlemore than half that. A turbine
234 turbines, which will provide 702 MW,about therunning at half speed produces alot less than half
same as a small power station. By comparison,its rated output.
theSiting is another problem. Manufacturers
Sizewell B nuclear station produces 1,188MW andrecommend that aturbine should be installed in a
Drax, the UK'slargest coal-fired plant, producesclear, steady airflow, wellaway from buildings or
4,000 MW.trees which cause gusting. In gustyconditions your
Wind power cannot produce a constant supply ofturbine will not produce its full output and islikely to
energy at everyhour of the day. We can still bewear out more quickly. Your roof top, especially
sure that the wind will blow onaverage for a givenintown, is not a good location!
number of days each year, and the amountIf you are not at home to use your electricity it's
ofenergy that can be harvested is considerable.difficult tostore but you can sell it back to the
The wind is free,and it's not controlled by anyonegrid. However, the pricepaid is about 5p/unit or
else. The Lewis wind farmcould produce about 1%less than half what you would pay tobuy it from
of the UK's electricity needs - when thewindyour electricity supplier. Your payback time will
blows.beextended.
When it doesn't blow there needs to be otherYou will save more money, more electricity and
generating plantavailable to meet demand.more greenhouseemissions by upgrading insulation
Managing the grid - balancing demandand supply -and buying low-energy lightbulbs, than by installing
is a highly skilled task. Demand fluctuatesa turbine on your roof. Wind power isnot a
butoutput from conventional power stations issolution to Britain's energy gap. Be prepared
relatively steady andpredictable. Output from aforblackouts!