Going Green With Solar, Wind, Or Biofuels is Not Easy

History is slowly being made. A few years ago,produce than energy from fossil fuel sources,
and for the first time, the U.S. Senate included apreventing it from becoming a serious contender
"renewable energy" requirement for utilities in itsin the area of "green" energy.
energy bill. Unexciting as this may appear at firstWind-power is also being considered by JEA, with
glance, the bill, after passing the House, requiredthe hope of building a wind-turbine farm along
most utility companies that now generate powerFlorida's gusty topographies. But the utility may
by burning fossil fuels to produce 10% of theirface opposition to this technology as well, believe
power from "renewable," or "green" sources suchit or not. In Massachusetts, for example, the
as solar energy, wind, geothermal wells, methaneAlliance to Protect Nantucket Sound is fighting the
gas from landfills, and biomass from farms by theestablishment of a 170-unit wind-turbine farm five
year 2020. Hydro-electric and nuclear energymiles off-shore, because they feel it would
sources were not included."industrialize" the area, and therefore degrade
To date, only 14 states have had enoughfishing, relaxation, and tourism. Senator Kennedy
foresight to adopt voluntary renewable energysupported the ban on wind-turbines in Nantucket
requirements for utilities, ranging from 1% inSound, deeply disappointing vast numbers of his
Arizona to 30% in Maine. Those states should belong-time supporters who felt bitterly betrayed by
given the recognition they deserve, because beinghis position.
"green" is not as easy as it sounds.JEA is now looking into the possibility of planting
Consider JEA, the city-owned utility of Jacksonville,trees on its own land, followed by fertilization with
Florida that volunteered in 1998 to provide 7.5%sewage. This program has the double advantage
of its power by "green" energy sources within 20of cleaning up local rivers while developing a
years. The utility's first foray into renewablesource of wood chips that could be used to
energy began with Arundo donax, a bamboo-likeproduce power more cleanly than fossil fuel
plant. JEA contracted with Biomass Industries Inc.combustion.
of Gulf Breeze, Florida to grow 12,000 acres ofWhere wind is plentiful in coastal areas and
Arundo. The plan was to shred and compost theMidwestern states, perhaps wind power will turn
plant, producing methane gas that would beout to be the short-term winner in the race to
burned to provide very clean energy forproduce clean energy. It is quiet, 100%
consumers at a price competitive with coal.pollution-free, and already able to compete with
The very organizations expected to support thefossil fuels on a cost basis. Apparently, more
Arundo project turned out to be its antagonists.people need to view high-tech wind turbines as an
Environmental groups were worried that Arundo,interesting and aesthetically pleasing technology.
a fast-growing plant native to the Mediterranean,Once the costs have come down, solar energy
would endanger Florida's indigenous vegetation.may come into its own. If utilities can find suitable
Florida's Sierra Club chapter asked JEA not toplants that don't offend local environmental
cultivate any more of the plant.groups, biomass may also make significant
One might think that Florida, with its abundance ofcontributions to clean energy. There are many
sunshine, could rely on solar energy to provide apeople who feel that the pieces of the
significant share of pollution-free energy. It would,clean-energy puzzle are here and that we need to
if not for the fact that solar energy research andfigure out how to put them together. The biggest
development has not been given the attention itlong-term winners will be the environment and the
deserves in the U.S., with the result that energyquality of life derived from cleaner air, water, and
produced from solar technologies, even in sunnysoil.
states like Florida, costs 10 times more to